School districts is probably THE NUMBER ONE thing I get asked about when talking to buyers who are considering relocating. This is not something ANY agent can answer with the clarity you are probably hoping for, but I can give you the resources to make an informed and educated decision.

First, should “good” schools even be part of your home buying criteria?

One piece of this puzzle you must think long and hard about is whether “good schools” should even be part of your criteria for a home. For some first-time buyers it is, for others, it’s the first piece of criteria that should be thrown out.

When to Throw Out “Good Schools” Criteria

When should you NOT have schools be part of your search criteria?  If you are a first-time home buyer and don’t plan to be living in your first home when your children are old enough to go to school, think twice about including it in your search criteria. For you, living in a particular “hip” or “trending” part of town might be more important at this point in your life and that’s okay!  Own it and enjoy every minute of that it while you are in that stage of life.  

For many of you, that sometimes means giving up  space to be closer to things like work or nightlife in order to stay within budget.  

Taking that a little further into the future, if that means your first home is going to be too small to raise the family plan to have years from now, throw the “good schools” criteria out and get everything else you want.  You have decided that you’ll move when it comes time to send kids to school … and that’s okay!  

Many first-time buyers do this and it makes their search so much easier so they can focus on a location without blowing the budget and not worry if they are buying into a “good” school district.  

And, when it comes time for resale, you’ll find similar buyers just like you who aren’t buying for schools.

And When To Keep Good Schools As A “Must Have”

If you are going to be buying your “forever” home as a first-time buyer, then YES, you definitely want school boundaries to be in your search criteria. That way you aren’t forced to move out of your home because you didn’t think far enough into the future.  

This decision is CRUCIAL in your search for a first home.  Pause and really think about it.  How long do you plan on living in this next home?  Does school-aged children fit into that timeframe?  

If you decide you are a homebuyer, first timer or not, who plans on living in your home when your kids are school aged, read on. We’ll tell you exactly how to think it all through and make the right decision.  

Next, “Buying for Schools” Checklist

1. Agents can’t give their opinion. Many clients are surprised that agents can’t offer any opinions on the quality of the schools or school districts because of fair housing laws. So don’t get frustrated when you ask about schools. Even if we were allowed to comment on schools, my opinion about schools may be different than yours, so it’s best for you to decide what makes a “good” school for your little ones.

2. Spend time researching schools and school districts. There are some good online resources where you can start learning about schools — www.greatschools.org and www.schooldigger.com are two such resources.  Use this link to access my exclusive resources to make researching schools effective and efficient for the Atlanta metro area.  

Remember that online ratings don’t always show the complete picture about a particular school or school district, and you should seek out other feedback too.  Talk to neighbors and friends, visit schools and meet with teachers and/or principals, and review test scores, graduation rates, and teacher-to-student ratios. 

Keep in mind that what you may deem as “good” may be slightly different from another family. Some families seek out smaller schools, more diverse schools, ones with specialized services, more-community based, or are open to both public and/or private schools. You know what’s best for your kids and family.

3. Spend time researching before you start house hunting. If schools are that important to you, don’t waste time house hunting without having done any research. Really get to know how the schools work in the general area you are considering. My clients are often surprised that there are more options than they first thought. This can really be a game changer when it comes to your home-buying decision making and where you narrow down your search.  

4. Don’t forget to confirm school boundary lines.  Always call the school administration yourself to find out what are the school boundaries and if your home’s location is within a certain parameter.  You should verify this information since it’s not always obvious or could be listed incorrectly by the seller. It’s not unusual that the school closest to your home may not be your school. Boundary lines do change from time to time … so always double check!  

5. Know that boundaries can change.  Keep in mind that whatever the boundaries are now, they can and likely will change over the years.  As communities grow and change, school districts go back to the drawing board and alter school boundary lines as needed. 

6. Learn more about all of the school options available. It’s not always clear-cut when looking at public school districts about what is available for students outside your boundary line.  Each district can have varying options and it’s worth your time to find out more information. 

There may be alternative options for schools your kids might be able to apply to and attend, such as magnet schools, charter schools.  Private or religious-based schools either and take the time to find out about costs, scholarships, and other requirements.

7. Expect to pay a higher price tag for some school districts.  Typically, a better school district means higher home prices (and possibly higher property taxes). So keep in mind the cost to move into a neighborhood with schools that have a good reputation. 

If you’re facing a higher price tag, then you may have to seek out other financing or adjust your criteria (i.e., living in smaller house or on a busy road).  But, on the other hand, you’ll likely have an easier time selling this more expensive home when it’s time to move. You’ll have to decide if it’s worth the extra expense.